Coconut pudding, anyone?!

If you’ve already made it, you know how creamy and delicious it is. And if not, then keep reading below and get this pudding in your life stat.

But first, let’s take a moment to adore one of my window sills in the new office studio space. 

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding Vital Proteins Gelatin #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding

You guys, I moved in to the new space the weekend of November 10, and I’m over-the-moon in love with it. I’m planning to show you more of it soon and what we are doing with it. 

The entire 2 bedroom apartment has hard wood floors, which is 100% my style.

After being in there over a week now and letting the new environment settle to my soul, I am confident that the whole look and feel is going to play off neutral colors, farmhouse-office style. But is that really any big surprise?!

My outstanding question is….why can’t it be a condo that I could just outright buy? But seriously. I’m never moving.

Anyways, early Saturday morning I went there to shoot this, drink lattes, and breathe in all the joys of work that never feels like work.

How Did You Come Up with Paleo Pudding?

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding

I’ll never forget when I first started playing with this recipe. 

It was October of 2013. Our friends, Missy and Jay and their daughter, Saige, were coming to California to visit. Ryan and I still didn’t have any of the kids yet, so back in those days, I spent all my time creating and concocting, developing and testing recipe upon recipe.

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding gluten free #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding

Almost immediately, I knew this one was going to be a hit. The way I always “test” that is by making a recipe and sharing it with people who don’t normally eat gluten, dairy, soy, corn, meat, etc., etc. free. When the recipe passed with flying colors, I knew it was a go.

Grass Fed Gelatin

All pudding uses gelatin, but only super high-quality pudding uses pasture-raised, grass-fed bovine hide gelatin. And why is this important? Because if we’re making food that supports gut healing, it needs to contain ingredients that aid in, not hinder, the healing process. 

I’ve already told you, hundreds of times, that I have long used gelatin for gut healing. HERE are all the reasons why.

If I’m consuming an animal-based product, then I need to know where, how, and why.

Gelatin is the foundation for this pudding recipe. Choose wisely.

BTW – if you want to get your high-quality gelatin from Perfect Supplements HERE, use my code GUTSY10 at checkout to save 10%.

Coconut Pudding {Paleo Banana Coconut}

Click HERE to save this post for later.

Coconut Pudding #coconutpudding #dairyfreepudding

This recipe is: gluten free, dairy free, soy free, corn free, added sugar free, and Paleo.

If you use a firm banana vs. ripened, it can turn into a low-FODMAP option as well.

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding Recipe

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Prep time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 4-6
A creamy, banana cream pudding perfect on its own or layered into a pudding parfait.
  • 2 medium bananas, extremely ripe
  • ½ cup full fat coconut milk
  • ½ cup coconut milk light
  • 1 egg yolk (if you cannot do egg yolks, you can just skip this ingredient)
  • 1-2 Tbsp Perfect Supplements Gelatin
  • 2 tsp vanilla extract
  • ¼ tsp sea salt
  1. Place bananas, full fat coconut milk, sea salt, egg yolk and vanilla extract in a medium bowl, and blend together with a Smart Stick (or a hand-held blender on low).
  2. Heat the coconut milk light on the stove (on low, and don’t allow it to bubble).
  3. Once heated, add the coconut milk light to your bowl, and stir in the gelatin by hand with a whip or spoon, making sure there are no gelatin clumps.
  4. Place entire mixture in the fridge for about 4 hours to cool and “gel” together.
  5. Serve with a non-dairy whip cream, sprinkle some shredded coconut/banana slices on top, and/or layer with crushed grahams/crushed banana chips.
Use 1 Tbsp gelatin if you want thin (almost runny) pudding; use 2 Tbsp if you want a firm pudding.

If you simply want to eat the Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding as-is, you can. I could eat the whole thing in one sitting. I’m good like that. 

However, when I made this recently, I turned it into a parfait.

I layered as such: crushed and dried bananas, Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding, crushed and gluten-free graham crackers, Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding, and a whipped cream topping. 

Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding dairy free #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding

Recipes Approved by All

Everyone in our house approved, and this is the perfect snack and dessert for the babies because it’s a free-from-all-the-junk pudding.

p.s. The whipped cream on top in this image is not dairy-free, but this is my favorite way to make a dairy-free whipped cream.

If you liked this post, you might also enjoy:

  1. Collagen vs. Gelatin
  2. The Leaky Gut Meal Plan book
  3. Paleo Popsicle Coffee Recipe
Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding Vital Proteins Beef Gelatin #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding


Paleo Banana Coconut Cream Pudding Vital Proteins Gelatin #paleo #paleorecipe #healthyliving #dairyfree #pudding

Similar Posts


  1. Pingback: Coconut Milk

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: